Non-Lord Editorial Gatekeeping
See moves README for orientation. This is the fifth design move.
The professional press’s filtering function — flagged as lost in Habermas’s 2022 update — is reconstituted in distributed, accountable forms.
Concrete features:
- Community-elected moderators with bounded terms.
- Transparent moderation logs.
- Appeals heard by a different moderator than the one who acted.
- Curator roles distinct from moderator roles (curators surface salient discussions; moderators handle norm violations).
-
Curator selections are themselves discussable.
- Why: Some gatekeeping is necessary for deliberative quality; the question is whether it is accountable.
- Cost: Slow. Politicised. Communities will fragment over moderation disagreements.